SERVING UPSTATE NEW YORK

Everything You Need for Your Next Car, Backed by Total Peace of Mind

Get a Free Vehicle History Report, access to Extended Warranties, Guaranteed Credit Approval, and at least $1,000 for your trade-in — plus $250 off your next purchase. Offer is limited each month with no obligation to buy. Claim your spot today!

(We’ve helped 2,000+ customers drive home in a reliable used car or truck in the last 24 months.)

LogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogo

Meet The Sales Team!

We know buying a used car can feel risky. You might wonder: Is it reliable? Can I get approved? Am I getting a fair deal? Will my trade be worth anything?

That’s why we built our process to remove the worry:

Free Vehicle History Report so you know exactly what you’re buying

Guaranteed Credit Approval so you never have to fear rejection

$1,000 Minimum Trade-In so you get real value for your car

Extended Warranty Options so you can drive with peace of mind

$250 Off Your Next Purchase of a used car, truck, or SUV

BONUS: Multi-Point Quality Assurance Checklist. We will check it all: brakes, engine, suspension, tires, and more

BONUS: Free Premium Detailing & Wash. Deep-clean inside and out so your ride looks flawless on pickup day.

We’ve helped thousands of drivers upgrade with confidence, and we’ll do the same for you!

Our goal is to never lose a customer over price.

Upstate NY’s Best Selection of Used Cars, Trucks & More

Sedans

SUVs

Trucks

Vans

Hatchbacks

Wagons

and more...

Frequently Asked Questions

What financing options do you offer?

We offer guaranteed credit approval and partner with 8 banks to provide financing for all credit types, including great, good, and bad.

Do you accept trade-ins?

Yes, we accept trade-ins! Bring your vehicle in for an appraisal, and we'll offer you a fair market value to put towards your new purchase, with a guaranteed minimum of $1,000 for any car you bring in to trade.

What’s your $1,000 minimum trade-in offer?

Push, pull or drag your car in. It doesn’t matter the condition. When you trade in your vehicle with us, you’ll get a guaranteed minimum of $1,000 toward the purchase of your next car. Even if your vehicle is worth less, you’ll still receive the full $1,000 credit. If it’s worth more, we’ll give you the higher market value.

Can I schedule a test drive online?

Yes, you can schedule a test drive by clicking any button on this site and choosing your vehicle. When you book from this page, you’ll also get a free Vehicle History Report, access to warranties, guaranteed credit approval, at least $1,000 for your trade-in, and $250 off your next purchase with no obligation to buy. Book an appointment and we’ll have your car ready when you arrive!

Do you offer warranties on pre-owned vehicles?

Yes, we offer extended warranty options on all of our vehicles!

What maintenance services do you provide?

Our service center offers a full range of maintenance services, including oil changes, brake repairs, tire rotations, and more, performed by certified technicians.

How can I apply for financing?

You can apply online anytime, 24/7, at ButlerAutoSales.com. It only takes a few minutes and is completely secure. Prefer to do it in person? Stop by our dealership and one of our experienced finance managers will guide you through the process and help find the best option for your budget.

Can I get financing with no credit or bad credit?

Yes! We offer financing options for everyone, regardless of credit history. A down payment may be required, but our finance team will work with you to find the best solution for your budget.

Can I see the vehicle’s history before buying?

Yes! We provide a free Vehicle History Report with every car so you can buy with confidence. You’ll see important details about previous ownership, service records, accidents, and more, all at no cost to you. Our goal is to make sure you have complete peace of mind before making your purchase.

How do I know I’m getting a trustworthy vehicle?

At Butler Auto Sales, our reputation speaks for itself. We’re rated 4.6 out of 5 stars by over 260 Google reviews, and we’ve been proudly serving customers in our community for more than 40 years. In just the past 24 months, we’ve helped 2,000+ drivers find and drive home reliable used cars and trucks they can count on. Additionally, we were voted “Best of the Best” Used Car Dealership by The Daily Star. When you buy from us, you’re not just getting a vehicle, you’re joining thousands of satisfied customers who trust Butler Auto Sales for honesty, quality, and long-term reliability.

What if I don’t know much about cars?

That’s okay, most people don’t! We take the time to explain every feature, history report, and maintenance record simply.

HAPPY CUSTOMERS

LogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogo
LogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogo
LogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogoLogo

…and thousands more!

REVIEWS

Great experience!! Nice people, after the purchase of my Durango decide to do the oil change over there and they treated me really good!

Massimo Cotza
06-07-2025

Just bought a new vehicle at Butlers Auto Sales in Sidney, NY Super friendly sales people. Fast, easy service. Fair trade in on my vehicle. Low price cars. Low interest. My wife and I are super happy! See Scott for sales.

Kevin Finnegan
11-06-2025

Professional staff all around from sales to shop to reception. And better, a great deal on used Nissan Frontier!!

Robi Da
03-06-2025

Jeff and everyone at Butler was phenomenal from the first phone call on.

Mike Woodward
02-06-2025

Super quick and helpful. Incredibly nice and straightforward

Victoria Weidig
20-05-2025

NONE STRONGER NONE BETTER. Getting stranded when your car breaks down on a road trip is awful but these guys got us sorted and rolling faster than we thought possible!

Robyn-Phalen Rayson
20-05-2025

Brian Brown
04-07-2025

Bill Fox
24-04-2025

The best place to get a car. Phil was amazing and walked us through the whole process. As first time car owners he made sure we understood

sarah Bakker
31-03-2025

Always willing to work with you! Second vehicle purchased thru them and the atmosphere and honesty is a huge plus for us!

Desiree Ruggles
26-03-2025

I appreciate everybody at Butler. Service is very trustworthy and they take care of all of our needs for all of the cars we own. Every vehicle we have purchased from Butler over the years has been very good quality.

Scott clayton
25-03-2025

This is an amazing business! Our salesman was Noah and he was very kind and patient with us, he did not make us feel stupid and didn't pressure us. He did everything he could to make it happen and answered every stupid question I had without judgement. Anything that I worried about Noah already had it figured out. We were truly blown away by his honesty, compassion and his professional abilities. If you're in the market for a vehicle, I highly recommend Butler Auto Sales, and be sure to ask for Noah! You won’t be disappointed. Thanks Noah!

Tara and Thomas
22-03-2025

Shain Bakker
13-03-2025

Jeff was great to work with. My husband and I couldn’t be happier with how our new car purchase went. 10/10

Summer Merithew
02-03-2025

Bill
15-02-2025

Ryan Luttinger
12-02-2025

100% recommend Scott to work with here! He is wonderful! Very helpful and friendly! Highly recommend! Ask for Scott when you walk in!

Mihai Musca
07-02-2025

I have two boys that just both purchased there cars. It was easiest and best experience we have had. I personally when ready will be going there to buy myself a new car. Thanks butler auto!!!!!

Christina Miller
27-01-2025

Amazing product line up and quality team. Jeff and Tyler were helpful and supportive. Thank you again.

Terri Slater
11-01-2025

This was definitely the easiest car purchase I've ever made thanks to Jeff Newman the best salesperson that I've ever dealt with . Thanks to the Butler family for my new beautiful Jeep !! I definitely recommend that if you need a vehicle, to make Butler auto sales your first stop , I'll bet it will be your last 😉

Stoner Steve
13-12-2024

I was referred by a co- worker to Butler Auto Sales after hitting a deer with are vehicle. Amber Lawson was our sales representative and we couldn't ask for a better person to help us with selecting our new car. We met her on Friday, we picked out a car that same day and got financed. By Monday afternoon we had are new car at home. I couldn't have asked for a smoother transaction. Thanks again to the sales team!

Toby Alter
06-11-2024

One of the best and nicest cars in NYS!

Bruno DiRico
21-10-2024

This platform has revolutionized our business operations. The seamless integration and powerful features have helped us scale our marketing efforts efficiently while maintaining excellent customer relationships.

Mark Neubauer
21-10-2024

Awesome place

Lolly Stanley
28-09-2024

Amber was great to deal with greatly recommend

Ronald
28-09-2024

Everyone was Great. Thank you Amber! We love the new truck. Highly recommend Butler auto sales.

Chrissy DiNardo
28-09-2024

Highly recommend Butler's. The owners are absolutely amazing. Mike and Tyler are great. The service department is top notch. Best experience buying a vehicle I ever had. They went above and beyond and with a smile all the way. Thank you

Tricia Jacques
28-09-2024

My first official car purchase through a dealership and it was a great experience. The process was explained clearly and went very smoothly. The vehicle was ready for me before I arrived and the handshake made me confident enough to know I chose the right dealership to begin my new adventure with a good vehicle. No gimmick lines, no sugar coating, and total transparency in the details. Leaving no question or worry. Amber made this a great day and the Butler Auto group ensures this is a great place to find a vehicle.

Deana Pereira
28-08-2024

Highly Recommend! ” Amber!!! 1000stars was great to work with and really went above and beyond to secure our desired car and ensure top quality. She had great work ethic with felt comfortable that she understood my needs as a mother and person in this economy also kept myself and son well informed along the way about timing and next steps. She was so amazing my son needed to be in school Friday and she came in on her off day to take care of everything for him! If that’s not amazing service what the heck is! It was a pleasure working with her and I would highly recommend Amber! Todd is cool too but he don’t play about gap insurance lol I’m happy we got it!

Cammy J her way
28-08-2024

Great service. Amber was awesome. Butler auto sales is a great place to get a car. Highly recommend

Stephanie Perry
28-07-2024

Always good service and friendly. Have a good working knowledge of cars I have taken to them

kid child
28-06-2024

The service department is far none the best in the area and I must thank Todd for ensuring I had a great warranty. A service appointment that should have cost me over $500 cost me “$0”. Thank you Brandon, Bumper, Charlotte & the men that make the service team fabulous!

Janine P
28-06-2024

Noah was great to work with made our process easy and was very friendly and helpful.

Justice Parks
28-06-2024

extremely helpful and easily communicated everything we needed to know !!

Savanah Mondore
28-06-2024

Amber Lawson did a tremendous job. Very professional and polite. Highly recommend

CreativeWings Screenprinting & Vinyl
28-06-2024

I just purchased a vehicle from Butler Auto Sales in Sidney, NY and wanted to give a shout out to the sales associate who assisted me. Scott was extremely patient and helpful while I was searching for a vehicle from their well stocked inventory. If you are looking for a knowledgeable, friendly associate, I highly recommend asking for Scott. Thanks again Scott!

Laurie Appley
28-06-2024

They are great people to deal with. We have bought cars from them for years and have always provided excellent service

Margaret Bivens
28-05-2024

If you are looking for a great used vehicle, check this place out!

Jeff Smith
28-05-2024

Khvicha Ch
28-05-2024

Thank you Amber!!!

Jaida Ramos
28-05-2024

Amber Lawson
28-05-2024

Patrick Ancewicz
28-04-2024

Great place to get a vehicle Sam is awesome for a salesman

marilyn voltz
28-04-2024

I purchased a 2017 Mitsubishi Outlander from Butler's back in 2018 for my growing family and it was a great car!! I just recently was able to trade in and upgrade for a beautiful 2021 GMC Acadia and Noah went above and beyond to help me find the right car. He was so patient, let me drive all the cars I had seen online (even stayed late to do so) just to be sure I was making the right choice, answered all my questions in stride, and also helped me weigh my pros and cons for each choice I had. Noah made the process effortless and I will HIGHLY recommend Noah, Todd, Tyler and the rest of team at Butler's to anyone needing to trade or find the right fit. Great people, excellent customer service and I'll be calling them before anyone else when I'm ready to trade again.

Ashley Marie
28-04-2024

Great staff, excellent service.

Kim Snyder
28-04-2024

Robert was an excellent person to work with def recommend him for any sales at butler

Sean Eggers
28-04-2024

Rob Bush helped us out greatly in making my fiancé's dreams come true! Very helpful and the process went quick and smoothly. Thank you so much!

Aislinn Smith
28-04-2024

It was great working with Robert! We are looking forward to driving our new Pacifica!

sherry hall
28-04-2024

Excellent every time.

Ron Haynes
28-04-2024

Great experience thank you butler

DarkAssassin
28-04-2024

Amber Lawson Is an excellent salesperson. It was a pleasure working with her, Amber and butler's rock! Thank you so much! Very pleased with the vehicle we purchased!

Bridget Kingsbury
28-04-2024

Connor Scott-Oakley
28-03-2024

Awesome place

Sam T
28-03-2024

Leo Yearry
28-03-2024

Highly highly recommend! Thanks Sam and the Butler team!

Chelsea Shannon
28-03-2024

Robert Bush was very helpful

John Thompson
28-03-2024

Craig Morrison
28-03-2024

Albert Jurczynski
28-12-2023

I love it here. They don’t have a long wait time. I love that you go outside and watch tv. Great places

Nichole Holling
28-11-2023

I recently purchased a 2016 Silverado 2500 from Butler Auto Sales. Noah went above and beyond to provide me with 5 star customer service. Unlike other dealers, Noah allowed me to take my time evaluating the truck with no pressure to purchase. He was available to answer any questions that I had and if he didn't have the answer, he would get back to me promptly after researching it. Will purchase from Butler Auto Sales again!

Jay B.
28-10-2023

Very courteous, friendly service

Janice richardson
28-10-2023

They are the best. I can’t say enough about Todd and Jeff who went above and beyond to make it happen. Was there on Wednesday and my new car was in my driveway Friday. Because of my husband not being able to get out of house they were kind enough to do everything from my home. I could never thank them enough for OUTSTANDING customer service. They definitely treat you like family. Thanks again for everything Dianne and Frank

Dianne Petrone
28-10-2023

Made the car buying process easy!

Sara Orum
28-10-2023

Sara Stevens
28-10-2023

Great people , great place

Kurt Carman
28-10-2023

Everyone at bulter auto sale were friendly and very helpful I'm definitely come back for my next purchase I'm loving my 2014 jeep compass thank you all for what you do be safe guys :)

John Fuller
28-10-2023

Debs Stoeckle
28-10-2023

Organized. Professional. Clean. The people are polite. Service is good as is waiting area with free coffee and tv.

Steve Shimer
28-10-2023

ToniAnn Deluca-Ancewicz
28-10-2023

Very friendly

JOE GALLAGHER
28-10-2023

Jonathan Thoma
28-10-2023

Great place! Have had my car for almost a year after purchasing from them. They make the process less daunting and make it clear what would be expected. The service center is knowledgeable and they even wash your car after. They only take cars that were bought here to service vehicles.

Bernadette Barbarise
28-10-2023

Bought my 4th car today from Butler, Best Buy yet thanks Brandon thanks for quick auto fix and good price yesterday

James “James” Harris
28-10-2023

Chris stanton
28-10-2022

Awesome 👍

Tom Beams
28-10-2022

Sherri Allen
28-10-2022

Good service good people

Michael Miller
20-06-2025

The nicest people to work with! Tyler was so nice and easy to work with to get my car serviced. Even just only interacting with people they were so kind. The building is beautiful inside!! They even kindly washed my car for me after it was serviced!

Victoria Tyrrell (Tori)
28-10-2022

Today I just bought my first car which was a 2016 Hyundai Elantra from Karl Higgins at Butler's Auto Sales. He was very respectable, curtosy, and he took his time explaining all the paperwork to me thoroughly. I would definitely recommend Butler's Auto Sales in Sidney NY. Not only that the dealership was very clean, roomy, and comfortable.

Dee Decker
28-10-2022

Had a pleasant time looking for a new to us vehicle. We were greeted as soon as we arrived. Salesman was not pushy at all. Let us walk the lot and investigate. Love that vehicles were all open and available to check out without having to find salesman and get keys for each one. Found a car we liked but did not commit to. We were given the Carfax report and other information beforehand so we could make an intelligent decision.

Jason Fletcher
28-10-2022

Excellent place to do business! All the staff are nice people!

Colleen Lindroth
28-10-2022

Great place to get car. Treat you good there .

Brenda Wilsey
28-10-2022

Ask for Phill.

R.c.p. Chambers
28-10-2022

Very clean the people that work here are very nice and helpful if you are buying or not very pleasant.

Daniel Kelsey
28-10-2022

Angela Bofelos
28-10-2022

Just purchased a Jeep. Wonderful group of people. No sales pressure. They took care of everything.

Kathy Schneidau
28-10-2022

Tom Paddock
28-10-2022

Sheldon Jacobson
28-10-2022

Bought a car here, years ago. No complaints.

Derek A
28-10-2022

Jon Nagy
28-10-2022

Five giant stars! After looking around for cars at a few different places, we came to Butler and our anxiety melted immediately. Jeff was instantly likable and trustworthy. I knew he was giving us 100% of his knowledge and attention. Not to mention his honest opinions. The car is a true gem for the price and I can't wait to go back for our next family car. Thanks a million, Jeff and Butler Auto!

Jon Davies
28-10-2022

Great 1st time experience buying a car on my own from a dealership. The salesman, Brandon, was wonderful, customer friendly, very patient and knowledgeable. If he could not answer a question he found the answer immediately. We had our picture taken with the beautiful clean vehicle (following covid-19 protocol, of course). Brandon then made certain I was familiar with the functions of the car, and he again was very patient in showing me. Mr. Butler made himself known to me and thank me for purchasing from him. I would definitely recommend Butler Auto Sales, Inc. to anyone as they were highly recommended to me from so many people. Anyone considering purchasing a vehicle, check out Butler Auto Sales, inc. first and ask for Brandon.

Debbie Stoeckle
28-10-2021

Great cars and trucks, nice helpful people!

Bruno Dirico
28-10-2021

Always have been treated great

Cheryl Fairbanks
28-10-2021

I was in need of a rental car after hitting a deer and Butler had one available. Wendy was great to deal with in the rental department and the car was great as well. Thank you Butler

Michael Singleton
28-10-2021

Always friendly and fair sales and service I can trust so I come back time after time

Faith
28-10-2021

Great doing Business with you Brandon Collins

Renay Morell
28-10-2021

Very awesome and quick service. Employees very helpful and curtious. Am very happy with my experience.

Pamela Sargent
28-10-2021

dale klein
28-10-2021

Pleasant fast friendly and courteous service best dealer in area

James Pierce
28-10-2021

Great service!!!!!!!!!!

Sally Nichols
28-10-2021

First time sale 6 years ago and all was well with the service and trade in. If all was well the first time than try again. Second time as good as the first. Thanks to Phil and all for everything.

Michael Hill
28-10-2021

Karen Keen Van Valkenburg
28-10-2021

Blair Walker
28-10-2021

Liam Champion
28-10-2021

Judith Sartell
28-10-2021

Always have been treated great

Cheryl Fairbanks
28-10-2021

This platform has revolutionized our business operations. The seamless integration and powerful features have helped us scale our marketing efforts efficiently while maintaining excellent customer relationships.

Elsie Roy
20-06-2025

+109 more

Get In Touch

Hours

Mon – Fri 8:30am – 6:00pm

Saturday – 9:00am – 2:00pm

Sunday – CLOSED

268 NY-7, Sidney, NY 13838, USA

Shop: 268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838

Site: www.butlerautosales.com

Copyright Butler Auto Sale Inc. 2025. All rights reserved